The Gundog Club

   
   
TRAINING ARTICLES  

HOME

 

REGISTER

 

SHOP

 

TRAINING

 

FORUM

 

CLASSIFIED

 

DIRECTORY

TRAINING ARTICLES  

Recall Problems

Preventing and solving common recall problems by Pippa Mattinson

 
 

A large proportion of the requests we receive asking for help are with recall problems.  As with many problems in all walks of life, where the ‘recall’  is concerned,  prevention is much better than cure.  Therefore this article will first take a look at how to establish a good foundation for  recall in your new puppy, including avoiding some of the more usual mistakes made by new owners.   Three common recall problems which are experienced regularly by dog owners everywhere are described, and we look at some solutions for restoring a good recall and with it hopefully, your peace of mind!

 
 

Your puppy is 'programmed' to follow you

 Recall problems as you have probably guessed, are created by dog owners.  All new puppies come pre-programmed to follow their human friends very closely.  And this is exactly what they do for the first two to eight weeks after you bring them home.   A new puppy will follow you devotedly,  right under your feet and frequently  trip you up in the process.   The puppy does this because the instinct to do so, is one that nature has designed in order to keep him safe from predators, and to make sure he doesn’t get lost.

 
 

Making the most of this close dependency

This ultra-dependent phase is often short lived  -  in some dogs,  very short lived.  So make the most of it.  Spend as much time as you can with your new puppy off the lead   -  following you around.  Change direction frequently,  try and sneak off every time he stops to sniff something.  Keep moving away from him and enjoy watching him come scampering after you.   This is hugely valuable training.  Every time he comes bouncing after you,  say his name,  sit on the grass and let him climb on you,  feed him,  fuss him,  do what ever turns him on.  Make it a brilliant experience every time he catches you up.   Try very hard to avoid walking in one direction with the dog running ahead of you all the time. Despite this being the most popular way for people to walk their dogs, it only serves to teach him that you will follow him and not the other way around,  and is the root of many a problem recall.

   
   

Common mistakes

  • Failing to condition the recall during the first few weeks. 

One frequently asked question is “when can I let my puppy off the lead”.  Sadly many people,  unaware of the lovely ‘following’ stage in learning and fearful that their puppy will run away,   keep their puppies on leads during the first few weeks.  This means that they miss out on this unique opportunity to let their puppy learn to follow them and to enjoy the recall.  

  • Walking in one direction

Never be predictable.  Your dog should have no idea which way you are going to turn next.  That way,  he will always keep an eye on you.  For this reason, the family walk is not always a good venue for training a young dog.

  • Chasing the puppy

Even worse, some owners actually chase their puppy, which teaches him to run away from them, rather than towards them.  It also teaches him that he can run faster than people can,  something he should never know.  This is a common problem in families with young children.  Never let anyone chase your puppy.  Ever.

  • Teaching the puppy to hate the lead

Other owners will have put their puppy on a lead at the end of each playtime and taught him to see the lead as something horrid.  Naturally,  he runs off every time the lead appears.    Remember to put on his lead many, many times each walk.   Feed or fuss him as the lead goes on,  and take off a few seconds later so that he associates it purely with pleasure.

 
    SPECIFIC PROBLEMS AND STRATEGIES  
   

Problem 1.  The dog that goes too far on a walk and only comes when he feels like it. 

This dog will often disappear for ten or fifteen minutes on a walk  -  eventually catching you up when you have shouted yourself hoarse and worried yourself silly for quarter of an hour.  He charges off when you first take off the lead,  and if he is more than twenty yards from you,  he usually ignores you when you call him, or comes in his own time with plenty of stops along the way.

Click here to read  the ‘about turn walk’  technique

 

Problem 2.  The dog that does not want to be caught.

This dog has learned to hate the lead.  He may recall quite well but will stop short of coming close enough for you to catch him.  This game can go on for ages,  with him dodging just out of reach, especially if he suspects that the walk is coming to an end and its time to go home.

Click here to read  the ‘I love my lead’ technique.  

 

Problem 3.  The dog that will not recall away from other dogs

This dog often comes back beautifully when there is no-one else around. However, as soon as another dog appears, he runs off and is completely deaf to your shouts and whistles.  Sometimes he will even follow another dog’s family all the way home or back to their vehicle, which is highly embarrassing, as it seems to demonstrate how little he cares for you.  

Actually, This is not a training problem as such, and has little bearing on how much your dog likes you.  It is the result of a misunderstanding that is very common  amongst dog owners. Recalling away from other dogs is an advanced training skill and has to be trained for specifically just like any other.   Some dogs (always other peoples dogs) don’t place a high value on playing with other dogs and are very easily trained to ignore them.  This is annoying for you but it cannot be helped.  You have to work with your dog-friendly dog and train him to recall in this challenging situation.   To train for this skill you will need the help of other dog owners,  and you will need to practice.  The procedure you will need to follow is known as 'proofing the recall' 

Click here to read 'proofing the recall'

 

Before you begin....

Before you think about proofing the recall it is important to make sure you are at the right stage in your training to do so.   For best results, training needs to follow a logical progression, with more advanced skills standing on the foundations of other core skills. To understand how important proofing is, and where it sits in relation to the rest of your training programme, it helps to have a brief look at the main stages in training a new skill and these are set out for you in the box below.

In the meantime,  think carefully about where you take your puppy....         

Most young  dogs and older puppies enjoy meeting other dogs.  Unfortunately not all other dogs enjoy meeting puppies, and some will even be aggressive towards your puppy, with potentially life-long consequences.  If the other dog is friendly, and engages your puppy in play, as a youngster with a short attention span he may forget about you entirely for a while. If he is too far from you to smell or see you when he decides he wants to go home,  then he will cling to the nearest friendly family, and this how he can end up following another dog home.  Most dogs do actually care where you are, and quite like to go home with you when they have finished what ever it is they are enjoying doing. It isn't personal.

The best way and safest way for puppies to interact with other dogs is in a controlled environment such as your garden or a friend's garden, with dogs that you know are friendly. Not with strange dogs he may come across on a walk.  For this reason, and to ensure you have the best possible chance of training him successfully we recommend the following:

When exercising or training a young dog, it is best to find an area completely away from the distractions of other people or dogs at very least until you begin to incorporate them into your training in a controlled way. I appreciate this is not always easy and may mean visiting your local recreation ground/park etc very early in the morning.  Long family walks are great for well trained adult dogs, who can accompany you at heel,  but not very useful for pups and young half-trained gundogs.  The use of the corner of a field or large garden for training purposes is of great value if you can possibly find one.  

 
   

Three Training Phases

It can be helpful to break the training process of any skill into its component parts.   Effective training can be broken into three phases

  1. Establishment of the behaviour

  2. Introduce new locations

  3. Proofing of the behavour

To begin with we ‘establish’ a behaviour.   This phase is where we show the dog what it is we like him to do,  and connect it with a cue word or command.   Next we begin to ‘generalise’  the behaviour,  or help him to understand that the command applies in a variety of different locations or situations.  Dogs are very poor at generalising and need some help to understand that the ‘here’ command  applies in the garden for example,  in the same way that it does in the house.   Finally we ‘proof’  the command.  This is where we get the dog to perform the actions we require under more and more challenging situations. 

Phase 1.  Establish the command

This is often the quickest and easiest part of the training process. Most people work quite hard on establishing a behaviour, often in a very positive and kindly way.  They take care to lure or gently place the dog in the correct position.  They give lots of practice and opportunity to learn and loads of positive feedback and rewards.  This stage is usually successfully completed by many dog owners. 

Once your puppy has been conditioned for several weeks to associate the recall command with the act of flying towards you,  then you can begin to use the command as a command,  rather than just as word association. Don't be in too much of a hurry to introduce compulsion into your training.  It is perfectly acceptable to wait until your dog is four or five months old before you start this kind of formalised training. The younger the puppy is,  the more important it is that you use effective generous rewards, and avoid corrections.  Start in one enclosed place,  free from distractions (your kitchen perhaps)  and be generous with praise when he arrives.  Use food if you want to,  you don't have to continue forever,  and can phase food out once the command is well learnt. To begin with, make it easy,  only call him if he is not busy with anything else. If he ignores you at any time,  go and get him.  Bring him firmly to where you were when you called him and then reward him as if it was all his own idea.  This will rarely be necessary if you use rewards that your  dog appreciates.  For some dogs,  praise is simply not sufficient and if you insist on relying on praise alone,  you may find yourself having to correct mistakes far too often.   When the dog is 100% reliable you can gradually reduce the ratio of responses which you reward.  When he is 100% reliable with just the occasional reward, in your first training location, you can move on to Phase 2.

 

Phase 2. Begin to generalise

Here is where things may begin to go wrong.  Not realising that the command has not been 'generalised',  the new owner often goes straight into this part of the training using corrections.   The dog has learnt to sit in the kitchen,  so the owner tells him to sit in the garden.  He fails to obey  -  not having a clue what she is on about  -  and gets a smack or a scolding.   He learns that sit means sit in the garden too.  He will probably get a few more smacks or tellings-off,  before he works out that sit actually means sit pretty much everywhere.   In the meantime,  a little more confusion is already creeping in because he finds out that actually, sit doesn’t always mean sit,  even indoors.   It might not mean sit if the phone rings,  or someone comes to the door.  It might mean ‘sit’  when one member of the family says it,  but not when another one does.  Frequently it doesn’t mean ‘sit’ unless it is said three times in a row  ....sit,  sit,  SIT!

It’s a lot for a dog to remember.  And coupled with that,  the once lovely kind owner is now turning into a bit of a  grump.  

To avoid this scenario,  begin the process of generalisation by teaching your dog each command in a variety of locations in just the same way as you did the very first time.  Use plenty of rewards and avoid distractions. You will see when 'the penny drops' and he starts to obey the command in lots of different places. Teach him to come in different rooms in the house,  in your garden, in a friends garden,  in a tennis court, any safe enclosure you can find.  Each time you go to a new location make sure he is successful and give lots of praise. Remember to avoid all strong distractions (other dogs, people, high winds, animals, traffic - anything which is taking his attention away from you).  Some dogs take this on board a lot quicker than others but they all get there in the end.   Each new skill that you teach,  will be generalised more quickly than the last.  Remember to be consistent.  Don't give commands that you do not have time to follow through.  Insist firmly that he obeys each and every time you give the command.  Don't give the command unless you are in a position to enforce it.  If you are frequently having to correct the dog you are probably not adequately rewarding him, or are trying to train where there are distractions. Set the dog up to win.  There will be challenges enough for both of you in Phase 3.

Phase 3. Proof the command

Having begun to generalise the command, with or without multiple corrections,  it is quite normal for the dog owner to now consider that his work here is done.  He may well now completely omit the longest and most important stage of training in its entirety.   In reality,  he has only just begun.

Proofing is really the major part of teaching your dog to generalise this command.  It is very challenging, as it includes practicing all the situations your dog is likely to meet on a regular basis, in which he may be required to obey your command.  It concerns the introduction of a wide  variety of distractions or 'factors of difficulty', which the dog must completely ignore whilst obeying the command he has already learnt and begun to generalise in a simple way.  This takes time, patience and repetition. 

The recall must now be taught under a variety of increasingly distracting circumstances, all of which must be controlled by you and presented in a structured and logical manner.  Determined proofing (not some kind of magical talent)  is usually what separates the successful dog trainer (amateur or professional)  from those who fall by the wayside.  The whole proofing process will be far more easily accomplished if you follow three basic rules. 

  • Follow a structured training programme

Structured training introduces new skills,  and proofs them,  in a logical sequence.  Simple skills should obviously be taught before advanced ones, but this is often forgotten or overlooked.  Make sure you Introduce mild distractions before strong distractions. Take care to introduce the most challenging distractions last of all  -  the most challenging distraction for a gundog is often live game or livestock.   If you cannot recall your dog away from another dog,  for example, you probably have little hope of recalling him away from a bolting rabbit.  The Gundog Club training guides set out a structured training programme for you to follow.

  • When you introduce one type of ‘difficulty’  reduce the others for a while. 

For example.  When you first recall your dog away from another dog,  make sure that  the other  dog is sitting quietly on a lead.  Don’t have the other dog running around. That is far too tempting and can come later.  Make sure you are close to your dog  -  distance erodes control.   You need to set this situation up.  Don’t wait for it to ‘happen to you’  on a walk.  Get a friend to help you and practice, practice, practice. Make the exercise more difficult gradually.  If you do not have a friend with a suitably quiet dog,  join a training club or book yourself onto a training course where you will have opportunity to train with other dogs in a controlled situation.  

  • Don’t rehearse errors or bad behaviour 

Anticipate problems and figure out how to avoid rehearsing mistakes.  Set the dog up to win.  Keep an eye open for other dogs (your long distance eyesight is probably better than his) and if you see other dogs coming whilst out with your puppy,  don't wait for him to spot them - make a lot of noise to attract his attention and  run in the opposite direction, keep the noise up if necessary,  to hold his attention  and keep running.  He will come after you.  Never 'poison' your recall command by using it on a  dog in a situation you have not trained for,  and where you cannot enforce it. If you fail to anticipate a problem and put him in a situation he isn't trained to cope with, it is your mistake not his.  You need to refrain from giving impossible commands, and if necessary, to go and get him.  You will also need to think about how to avoid the situation arising in the future.   People get themselves into a dreadful pickle worrying about what to do when the meet other dogs in Park X.  They feel that their dog should be better behaved there,  or that they should be able to cope with him there.  They convince themselves that everyone else's dog is better behaved than theirs or that they are a failure as a dog trainer. When actually it is an inappropriate place to train off lead, and they are trying to achieve the unachievable.   It is easy to get into a routine of going to a particular place without really considering what purpose it is actually serving.  Very often the simple solution of avoiding Park X until the dog is better trained is a great relief to them.   

 
   

Just occasionally an owner will have a serious recall problem where the dog genuinely runs away.  He doesn't look back, isn't interested in where the owner is,  and stays out until he is either hurt or lost and remains so until (if he is lucky) someone finds him and brings him home.  This kind of situation is unusual and is probably most likely to arise when an older dog has been rehomed or rescued.  A successful recall can be taught to the 'absconder' but it may take many months of careful training.  We will look at retraining the recall in the absconding dog in another article.  Help should be sought from a behaviourist for dealing with an absconding dog, and precautions taken to ensure his safety  The chances are that your dog does want to go home with you at some point,  and that applying a structured training approach consistently will solve your problem and restore the good relationship between the two of you.

 
   
We hope you found this article useful.  If you would like to make any comments or suggestions on the subject of recall problems,  why not drop in to the Gundog Club Forum for a chat

THE FORUM

If you would like to contact The Gundog Club to enquire, or comment, about any aspect of our graded training scheme or  courses, you can also telephone 01428 717529 or email   admin@thegundogclub.co.uk

 
         

THE GUNDOG CLUB  -  01428 717529   -  IT'S NOT A COMPETITION

   

Unless otherwise stated,  all text and images on this website belong to The Gundog Club and may not be reproduced without written permission

 Copyright©The Gundog Club 2005, 2006,2007 All rights reserved